Welcome to Old Pueblo Grill
At Old Pueblo Grill, located in the heart of Rochester, NY, tradition meets flavor in a vibrant celebration of Mexican cuisine. With signature offerings like the loaded Quesadillas and tantalizing Taquitos, this restaurant invites patrons to indulge in authentic flavors that transport them straight to the Southwest. The diverse menu also features daily specials, ensuring there's always something new to savor, from Shrimp Tacos to the signature Flamin' Hot Cheeto Burrito. The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with friendly service, creates the perfect backdrop for enjoying these culinary delights, making each visit a memorable experience filled with warmth and exquisite tastes.
- 55 Russell St, Rochester, NY 14607 Hotline: (585) 730-8057
Introducing Old Pueblo Grill, a vibrant destination for Mexican cuisine located at 55 Russell St, Rochester, NY 14607. With its unique blend of flavors and a welcoming atmosphere, Old Pueblo Grill sets the stage for a delightful culinary experience. Whether you're a taco enthusiast or a fan of hearty burritos, this restaurant has something for everyone's taste.
As you step inside, you'll be greeted by an inviting ambiance that feels both casual and lively. The spacious interior is perfect for gathering with friends or enjoying a quick bite during your workday. You can expect quick service without sacrificing quality, as numerous customers have noted the fast and friendly staff. From the moment you place your order to the first delicious bite, Old Pueblo Grill focuses on delivering an incredible dining experience.
Now, let’s dive into the mouthwatering menu highlights that have diners raving:
- Taquitos: These flavorful delights are filled with red chili beef and wrapped in corn tortillas, served with refreshing pico, guacamole, and a dollop of crema. A steal at $12.00.
- Quesadilla: A classic favorite, this dish features melted Mexican cheese with your choice of protein, paired with all the fixings for only $12.50.
- The Chimi: A deep-fried burrito packed with carne asada or carnitas, this dish is a satisfying choice at $15.00, accompanied by guacamole and crema.
- Super Nachos: Indulge in crispy chips (or fries!) topped with an array of ingredients like Mexican cheese, queso, and pickled onions for just $13.00. Pro tip: add chicken or grilled shrimp for an extra boost of flavor!
Don't miss their daily specials, such as the Navajo Taco on Wednesdays or the ever-popular Flamin' Hot Cheeto Burrito on Saturdays, blending tradition with a twist. The Taco Trio allows you to mix and match for just $14.00, ensuring everyone can find a favorite.
Customer feedback overwhelmingly praises the culinary delights and atmosphere. One visitor highlighted the magical taste of the Flying Hawaiian taco, claiming it lingers in memory long after the meal. Others have expressed appreciation for the gluten-free options available, making it easy for all dietary preferences to enjoy.
It's clear that Old Pueblo Grill isn't just about food—it's about community, welcome service, and quality dishes that transport you to Mexico with each bite. With an exciting menu and passionate staff, it's no wonder that this restaurant has quickly become a favorite among locals.
So, if you’re in the Rochester area, make sure to stop by Old Pueblo Grill. Bring your appetite and get ready to savor some of the best Mexican cuisine around!

Great food and excellent customer service. The cashiers tonight were so sweet! The kitchen was a little behind but my order was still right and delicious! You have my business forever!

Inside was much larger than I expected when we place our order. I thought the wait would be long as the line was too the door but we got through it quickly. They said 30 mins for food but only waited about 12 or so minutes. Had the variety ...

Stopped in Old Pueblo Grill for lunch. Everything looks and smells so good. I decided to go with 3 tacos. The Flying Hawaiian taco is absolutely fantastic! The flavor of this taco will have you dreaming about it for days! My ...

The service was fast, and the tacos i had reminded me of San Diego California. Gluten Free Options are available. Staff knowledgeable and outgoing. It was empty when I came in, but quickly ...

Customer service was fast, kind helpful with it being our first time there. The food came out quickly the atmosphere was calm peaceful. Will be back !!

Hell ya this spot is sick. Delicious tacos, I had 3 different tacos and all those brought me to the flavor town, so good! outdoor seating was cool too. 1010 would recommend this place.

Watch out Chipotle! Everyone was friendly and everything was fresh and a great selection. I had three tacos and each was wonderful. My daughter had yummy and crisp taquitos. It was clean, including the bathroom. We cant wait until the Victor location opens.

The Best! 1st time visiting today and I am beyond impressed. Everything we ordered was absolutely amazing and We tried the fish tacos, queso, quesadilla, the bacon hot dog, guacamole, and a ton of other tacos. Plus Skins! and I cant say which was my favorite i loved it all, my whole family enjoyed. ...